Opening page…
An open question
Society
Punishment without a payoff
Suppose punishing a guilty person would deter nobody, protect nobody, and change nothing. Would they still deserve punishment?
Separate punishment as a useful tool from punishment as something a wrongdoer deserves. Decide whether suffering can settle a moral debt.
From around the house
Sign in to see the notices, scenes, and arguments the house has gathered around this question — and to raise it yourself.